Sonic x Shadow: Generation is a dual campaign experience that merges nostalgia with innovation for the franchise, aiming to please both classic fans and newcomers to the Sonic franchise. While Sonic’s campaign, Sonic Generations, is almost exactly the same as the 2010s original, Shadow’s campaign, Shadow Generations, diverges into new territory with updated mechanics, a fresh story, and a deep dive into Shadow’s character arc. This ambitious setup establishes Sonic x Shadow: Generation as an exciting but uneven package, where the two campaigns contrast sharply in quality and innovation.

The differences between the two campaigns become immediately clear. Sonic’s portion, while remastered in 60 FPS for smoother gameplay, remains mostly a visual upgrade of the original Sonic Generations built on the Hedgehog Engine 1 (HE1). Unfortunately, the remaster does little to modernize the experience beyond the FPS enhancement, leading to a familiar but arguably underwhelming gameplay loop that may feel dated by today’s standards. Longtime fans might appreciate the nostalgia, but others may see this as a missed opportunity for greater innovation or enhancements.

In contrast, Shadow Generations brings a breath of fresh air to the experience. Built on the Hedgehog Engine 2 (HE2), the game features a fluidity that’s notably improved over recent entries like Sonic Frontiers. The gameplay feels responsive and polished, leveraging HE2’s capabilities to showcase enhanced graphics, seamless transitions, and refined mechanics. The levels in Shadow Generations provide a satisfying blend of fast-paced action and platforming, with revamped classic stages that take full advantage of Shadow’s unique abilities. This version of Shadow, both stylistically and mechanically, feels like a product of thoughtful design and careful consideration, marking a significant step forward in gameplay.

The storyline of Shadow Generations is also a highlight. Serving as a quasi-sequel to Shadow the Hedgehog (2005), the campaign reintroduces Black Doom, who returns as a central antagonist. This narrative direction allows players to explore Shadow’s growth from a former villain to an antihero, reflecting on his complex past while revisiting iconic levels from earlier games. This time-traveling journey through Shadow’s story strikes an emotional and introspective tone, giving players insights into Shadow’s motivations, struggles, and evolution. Shadow Generations achieves what few Sonic titles have attempted: a nuanced portrayal of Shadow’s character that makes him feel both relatable and compelling.

However, while Shadow Generations elevates the overall experience, Sonic’s campaign feels more like an add-on intended to boost the game’s appeal and sell more copies. Although this approach isn’t necessarily a drawback—Sonic Generations remains an outstanding game—it does create an imbalance in the overall package. The two campaigns differ markedly in substance, with Shadow’s campaign offering fresh mechanics and a deeper narrative, while Sonic’s largely delivers a familiar experience. This setup may lead players to feel more drawn to Shadow’s journey, which brings more novelty and character depth.

In conclusion, Sonic x Shadow: Generation is a standout entry in the Sonic franchise and a must-play for fans and newcomers alike. With the innovative and engaging Shadow Generations campaign, the game brings new life to the series, offering a fresh and in-depth exploration of Shadow’s character, alongside nostalgic elements that feel updated and revitalized. While Sonic’s campaign may feel more like a familiar add-on, its classic appeal still holds up well. Altogether, Sonic x Shadow: Generation earns a solid A- and stands out as a strong contender in platforming, giving even Nintendo’s Mario series a run for its money.